I showed you the incongruous Johnson City sofa in yesterday’s shot but here it is again in close-up. I hadn’t intended posting this today but David Nightingale posted his shot of the sofa today so I reckoned it would be appropriate after all.
Comparing the two shots, I definitely prefer David’s. I deliberately shot from a higher position to minimise the amount of sky in the frame but his shot, which is taken from lower, works rather better, I reckon, regardless of the brighter background.
I seem to remember a few years back that there was a photographer who carried a red, Chesterfield sofa around a bunch of US landmarks and photographed it against dramatic backgrounds. The background here isn’t particularly exciting but I wonder if this was the last stop in the tour?
I actually like them both the same.
Scott´s last post ..There she is- Miss America 6-52
Dave that’s the kind of photo I love man. NIce job!
Tom Baker´s last post ..POTD- Plaza Towers
I like your composition more than Nightengale’s, Dave. But I feel better about the color tone of David Nightengale’s image. Regardless, both of you have demonstrated how the incongruity of a found object to its surroundings makes an interesting image.
Wayne Frost´s last post ..Never Let A Threat Of Rain…
I think you’re being a bit harsh on your version – it’s very effective.
djn1´s last post ..untitled 115
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Dave Wilson, Oscar Navarro ?. Oscar Navarro ? said: From:@dawilson Incongruous Sofa, Johnson City, Texas: I showed you the incongruous Johnson… http://bit.ly/hPxMwi #Photog #Photography […]
Scott – ever the diplomat 🙂 Thanks.
Tom – glad you like it!
Wayne – as ever, it’s all down to personal taste. I prefer David’s composition but am not 100% sold on his magenta foliage.
David – many thanks. Some guy taught me these really useful colour modification tricks last weekend 🙂
Dave I have not seen David’s photo yet but this photo would be hard to beat. What a capture!
Thanks Mark! Oddly enough, I found the sofa in another of the blogs I follow today. You can find it in the middle of Carol Watson’s post today too.
[…] another picture in my occasional and very small “Incongruous Sofa” collection. I spotted this one yesterday in the hay barn at Rippy’s Feed Store in […]
Passing here, and I stopped to see this excellent publication, because we also work with a tailor made sofa
Congratulations